Key Reported Cases by Lawyer Yair Cohen

The Case of Kirat Assi v Simran Kaur Bhogal

The case of Linsey Goldrick Dean v Paul Curran

The case of Nicola Brookes v Facebook and Persons Unknown

The case of GYH v Persons Unknown

The case of DDF V YYZ

THE CASE OF MARIO ROGERS

THE CASE OF XLD V KZL

THE CASE OF RADA-ORTIZ V ESPINOSA-VADILLO

THE CASE OF R V SABINE MCNEILL

THE CASE OF R V PAUL BRITTON

The case of Kirat Assi V Simran Kaur Bhogal

Case summary

The case of Kirat Assi V Simran Kaur Bhogal is believed to be the longest case known of catfishing and the first successful civil claim in the UK relating to catfishing. The victim, Harkirat Assi, was catfish by a distant family relative who, over a decade, created and impersonated more than 50 different characters.

Some of the characters who were impersonated by Simran, were known to her victim as real people. Furthermore, Simran herself befriended her victim to become one of her most trusted friends with whom her victim shared worries, concerns, and suspicions.

She created for her characters who became needy and dependent on her victims and with whom, for various reasons, her victim could not meet in person.

Some of the impersonated characters lived overseas whilst the main character, just before he was about to meet with the Simran’s victim in person, had suffered fatal injuries and remain critically ill and paralysed for nearly 5 years.

During his illness, the fatally injured character, who was called Bobby, had become emotionally depending on Simran’s victim, threatening to commit suicide if she terminated her relationships with him.

Following a decade long of deceit, and only after her victim contacted the police, Simran finally made a confession which, of course, devastated her victim.

Case outcome

Following nearly 18 months of litigation, Simran Kaur Bhogal agreed to pay Kirat Assi substantial damages and her legal costs. She also provided her with a formal letter of apology.

Learn more about the case

The Internet Law Centre

The longest catfishing case in the history of the internet

Spotify

Daily Mail


Brought to you by Daily Mail

The case of Lindsey Goldrick Dean v Paul Curran

Case summary

The case of Lindsey Goldrick Dean is believed to be the longest lasting harassment case in the UK.

Her harasser stalked her over a period of 13 years, sending her and family, friends and work colleagues harassing letters first and then links to dozens of website that he created about her.

Paul Curran also took out Google AdWords to promote his harassing websites about his victims. Through his websites, he followed every aspect of his victims’ life, her marriage, her pregnancy, her giving birth, her celebrations and her moments of sadness and agony. Paul Curran attached himself to his victim’s life and he wasn’t going stop.

Over the years, Ms Goldrick Dean involved the police on at least 4 occasions but each time the police let her down, the harassment because more and more acute.

Lindsey was unable to find a lawyer to take on her case. She was financially broke and as time went by, the volume of evidence became higher and higher until she nearly lost hope.

Case outcome

Following just over 12 months of litigation, Paul Curran agreed to pay his victim damages and her legal costs. He has refused to publicly apologise for his conduct.

However, a statement of vindication which included his apology was read in open court, giving Lindsey a closer.

Learn more about the case

The Internet Law Centre

Lindsey Goldrick Dean v Paul Curran (internetlawcentre.co.uk)

Channel 5 News

Daily Mail


Brought to you by Daily Mail

This morning

The case of Nicola Brookes v Persons Unknown

Case summary

The case of Nicola Brookes paved the way for thousands of online abuse victims to demand that Facebook and other social media companies reveal the identity of internet trolls to their victims.

Nicola Brookes was trolled by anonymous Facebook users after she “dared” defending an X Factor contestant, who himself was being bullied online.

After giving up hope that the police will provide her with support, determined Nicola contacted dozens of lawyers with the hope of receiving legal support to try and identify her tormentor. Eventually solicitor Yair Cohen agreed to take on her case on a pro-bono basis.

Case outcome

Nicola’s case made history of being the first ever case where Facebook was compelled to provide personal information about her users following an historic injunction application before the High Court in London.

Once the information was received from Facebook, it became clearer why the police might not have been as helpful as they should. The main internet troll who tormented Nicola, was a police officer himself.

Learn more about the case

Daily Mirror

Mum’s ten years of trolling hell for the ‘crime’ of defending X Factor contestant

Daily Mail


Brought to you by Daily Mail

THE CASE OF GYH V PERSONS UNKNOWN

Case summary

In the case of GYH v Persons Unknown [2018] EWHC 212 (QB) Yair Cohen acted for a client who was a transgender and who worked as an escort. The case concerned online reviews and other publications, mainly on adult advertising websites, which sought to humiliate GYH and harm her private clients escort business.

The reviews and publications disclosed the fact that GYH a transgender and they published false claims that she was practicing unsafe sex and that she had HIV. This significantly harmed her business and her ability to continue to see her wealthy clients

Case outcome

GYH was granted a privacy injunction to protect her privacy and her right to maintain her gender undisclosed to potential clients an to protect her private medical information, so far as the unsubstantiated claims about her HIV positive status went. GYH was also granted an injunction under the protect her from harassment, under the Protection from Harassment Act.

Furthermore, she was granted a number of third party disclosure orders (NPOs), including one against Virgin Media, which eventually disclosed the identity of the broadband account holder, from which the harassing posts had been posted.

Learn more about the case

Internet Law Centre

Privacy cases in the UK (internetlawcentre.co.uk)

Read full judgement

Privacy injunction solicitor (internetlawcentre.https://www.internetlawcentre.co.uk/images/GYH-v-Persons-Unknown–EWHC-3360-privacy-injunction.pdfco.uk)

Inform.org

Case Law: GYH v Persons Unknown, Transgender Escort wins right to harassment damages – Media Lawyer – Inforrm’s Blog

THE CASE OF DDF V YYZ

Case summary

In the case of DDF v YYZ, Solicitor Yair Cohen acted for a celebrity who had been harassed on the social media platform Instagram by an anonymous Instagram user.  As it would take some time to establish the full identity of the harassing Instagram user, it was necessary to make changes to the, then, current service of legal documents rules to include a presumption of good service, when the injunction is served through the very same social media platform where the harassment is taking place.

Case Outcome

DDF was granted the right to serve the harassment injunction on the anonymous defendant via the social media platform Instagram. The significant of this permission is that the court can now recognise the service of injunctions on offending social media users, via the social platform they use as good, lawful and appropriate alternative service method. This means that an offending social media user who had been served with an injunction via the platform, could be liable to imprisonment for contempt of court, if they breach the injunction

Learn more about the case

Internet Law Centre

https://www.internetlawcentre.co.uk/online-harassment-injunction-legal-advice/social-media-harassment-celebrity

Law Society Gazette


Brought to you by Law Society Gazette

How to serve an injunction via Instagram

Celebrity Trolls: We’re Coming To Get You

Upcoming Events

May 2020

The Internet Law Leadership Summit 2020

14 May 2020  -  15 May 2020

The annual gathering of the most prominent internet law lawyers and attorneys from across the world

From 09:00 until 17:00

At Aria Hotel, Las Vegas

Find out more...

April 2020

The Data Protection Practitioners' Conference 2020

06 Apr 2020

The annual ICO conference with Information Commissioner, Elizabeth Denham CBE

From 08:30 until 17:00

At Manchester Central Convention Complex

Find out more...

    Finally, it's coming. Soon, hopefully in the UK victims of #harassment and #defamation will be able to unmask their abusers without having to need me! Australia to introduce new laws to force media platforms to unmask online #trolls https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/australia-introduce-new-laws-force-media-platforms-unmask-online-trolls-2021-11-28/

    ‘People are nasty as hell on there’: the battle to close Tattle – the most hate-filled corner of the web. I have been quoted in today's Guardian #harassment #onlineharms #celebrity https://www.theguardian.com/society/2021/nov/24/people-nasty-as-hell-on-there-battle-close-tattle-most-hate-filled-corner-web

    There are a few challenges for #celebrities seeking right to be forgotten but this does not mean that a #celebrity cannot have information removed from social media or from Google searches #remove
    https://arighttobeforgotten.co.uk/right-to-be-forgotten-example/right-to-be-forgotten-by-celebrities

    Questions & Answers for common online harassment queries! Have a read to learn something new: https://harassmentlawyer.co.uk/online-harassment-questions-and-answers #harassment #lawyer #socialmedia #online #legal #advice #blackmail #CyberBullying #education

    Shannan Watts' brother raising funds to fight trolls blaming her for Chris Watts' crimes #ShannanWatts
    #FamilyAnnihilation
    #domesticviolence #onlineharassment #onlineharmbill #OnlineSafetyBill #DomesticAbuse https://tinyurl.com/3hvkr9e7

    Load More...